MyFox
 

RandyTravis' Blog

by RandyTravis from Fox5 I-Team

Last Post 12 days, 7 hours Ago


The state of Georgia acted quickly when we disclosed the results of an I-Team investigation into a local elevator maintenance company and its contract with DeKalb County government.

The Georgia Department of Labor licenses elevator maintenance companies. It also inspects elevators after the maintenance company supposedly does a comprehensive safety test. The company proves they did the test by leaving behind a little metal test tag attached to the guts of the elevator system.

But we heard from a former employee of Advantage Mobility and Elevator Solutions that the boss wanted his employees to put tags on certain county elevators without actually doing the tests, thus fooling the state inspectors.

In our surveillance audio, the boss is heard saying "we don't want to cause ourselves no problems. I believe a lot of these cars haven't been tested in a long time. We f*** around trying to do it right, we're going to f*** ourselves."

The state issued a cessation order for the company, ordering them not to work on any more elevators until a hearing can be scheduled.

A California company called Elevator Load Test www.elevatorloadtest.com says that some companies don't like to properly test elevators because it involves heavy weights and takes hours for each elevator.

But Ron Creak, a nationally known elevator expert, www.creak-moskal.com says he prefers the way testing is done in states like Texas and Florida. They certify private individuals to witness the testing take place, rather than take the maintenance company's word for it. He flew to Georgia to examine DeKalb County's troubled government elevators.

What do you think? Do you like Georgia's way of inspecting elevators? Have you ever had an issue on an elevator that left you concerned about your safety?

15 Comments |  Add a Comment

Member Comments Total Comments: 15
Page 1 of 1
Foxnewshound
Feb 11, 2008 | 7:35 PM

Thank God that somebody is going to get the elevators checked properly in the buildings in Decatur (and hopefully fixed right). The ones in the front part of the courthouse have dropped several inches after the doors open, then rise back up level with the floor. People trip getting on or off. They've gotten stuck between floors many times and the fire department had to be called to get people out of them. I have gotten off of them 4 or 5 times when they felt too full of people on the first floor. And, again, sometimes they would drop when they got very crowded. This has gone on for years. That 125% testing rule sounds like a great idea.

And the doors in the Maloof building elevators sometimes slam shut and sound like a jail door closing. That really makes you wonder if they're working right.

I sure hope that now they will get fixed and work right.

foxtrot711
Feb 11, 2008 | 10:15 PM

Just remember that not ALL Georgia Elevator companies take the easy way out! I happen to work in a building downtown that has a very good elevator company. The service technician, Gordon, is there, every month, doing routine maintenance, and when there is ever a problem, his company fixes it in a timely manner. Remember, the elevator company in Mr. Travis’ story does not represent every elevator company.

BonnieY
Feb 11, 2008 | 11:15 PM

Does Ames have anything to do with the inspections of Gwinnett Medical Center? A patient stepped off the 8th floor a few months back with no car in the shaft and died. Has any connection to this situation been made?

RandyTravis read my blog view my photos
Feb 11, 2008 | 11:22 PM

I have not heard about that one. Write me directly at randy.travis@foxtv.com with more details.

If there's something there I'll report it on this blog as well as on the air.

BonnieY
Feb 11, 2008 | 11:32 PM

Okay, I will try to find the newspapaer article
and forward it to you.

jkw58
Feb 12, 2008 | 7:29 AM

mr. travis thanks for reporting what you did . I happen to work in the elevator bussiness in atlanta and have since 1998 I work for one of the larger elevator companies. I am also a member of the IUEC local 32 elevator constructors union.I have never seen anything like this in my years.I have never done an inspection with out a state inspector present did not know you could.I just want your viewers to know we take alot of pride in what we do. We also very much understand that the publics saftey is in our hands.My job is not worth someones life. Anyone that thinks so has no business in our business.Sometimes the lowest bidder isnot the right bidder.

Janet66
Feb 12, 2008 | 10:16 AM

Randy, thanks for doing this story. I've personally not known of any problem as this, but it's certainly an important one which everyone should know about if they use elevators. We have an elevator in our building, but it is maintained properly.

Karen

RandyTravis read my blog view my photos
Feb 12, 2008 | 12:53 PM

jkw58:

You do have to be there when the inspectors show up. But the inspectors don't have to be there when the maintenance company does the annual and 5 year tests. The state simply trusts that the information left on the test tag is accurate.

Foxnewshound
Feb 12, 2008 | 6:04 PM

I think jkw58 hit the nail on the head. From what I've heard from past employees DeKalb's maintenance department has a bad habit of always taking the lowest bids, and repairs take weeks or months that DeKalb employees used to do in a few days.

As for the elevator industry in general, I'm sure there are many fine and competent elevator technicians out there, and I thank them for making the elevators they work on safe. How often do you really hear about elevator accidents? Not very often at all.

bookemdano
Feb 13, 2008 | 2:31 PM

Across the street from the main courthouse complex is a building called the Callaway Building (it too belongs to the county). One of the two elevators located in the Callaway Building was not working first thing this morning.

RandyTravis read my blog view my photos
Feb 13, 2008 | 2:47 PM

The Callaway Building is one of the trouble spots we pointed out in our investigation. The state said the two elevators passed a new weight load safety test over the weekend. Sounds like there are still problems.

We're working on some other aspects to this investigation. Keep me posted here or directly at randy.travis@foxtv.com

Thanks

Foxnewshound
Feb 13, 2008 | 10:17 PM

The elevators in the Callaway building have been a problem for many years, even when the County had a reputable elevator maintenance company. Many people have gotten stuck in them. Fortunately, they are enclosed by glass so you could see when someone was stuck and they could see that help was coming. I think they're just old and need to be completely and totally replaced - cars, doors, motors, wiring and electronics. That probably won't happen as the building was suppose to be sold off, and I assume still is.

omarsm01 read my blog view my photos
Feb 17, 2008 | 11:18 AM

I have had a women trapped in an elevator at a building I was doing work at, I immediatly called the property manager and he called the elevator contractor and they were out there within 45 minutes; Does the department of labor actually have people on there staff that can test an elevator? How can they tell if it was done properly if they don't know how to do it? It appears that someone has been pencil whipping documents, and if they bring in a third party, whos to say they won't pay them to look the other way, the government today is so corrupt, you don't know who to trust anymore.

utmostdisgust
Feb 25, 2008 | 12:32 AM

How do I get to the I-Team blog on Dirty Hotel Glasses? I was keeping up with it but now when I try to go to it, the link takes me to some individual's blog site.

RandyTravis read my blog view my photos
Feb 25, 2008 | 5:49 PM

Dana Fowle would love to hear from you. Go to her blog. She just finished up another update on her dirty hotel glasses investigation.

Page 1 of 1


Write your comment below:




RandyTravis

I've been a WAGA reporter since 1990. I joined the Fox5 I-Team in 1994. I grew up in Athens, Georgia, the son of a UGA professor and a hard-working mother of four. And I covered UGA sports during some of the greatest sports years in school history before graduating there in 1982. These days I spend my time traveling across our state, looking for examples of government waste, corruption, consumer fraud and anything else that I think you'll find interesting and important.

Member Since: 2/28/2007